Quick Guide to Microservices with Spring Boot 2.0, Eureka and Spring Cloud

There are many articles on my blog about microservices with Spring Boot and Spring Cloud. The main purpose of this article is to provide a brief summary of the most important components provided by these frameworks that help you in creating microservices. The topics covered in this article are:

  • Using Spring Boot 2.0 in cloud-native development
  • Providing service discovery for all microservices with Spring Cloud Netflix Eureka
  • Distributed configuration with Spring Cloud Config
  • API Gateway pattern using a new project inside Spring Cloud: Spring Cloud Gateway
  • Correlating logs with Spring Cloud Sleuth

Before we proceed to the source code, let’s take a look on the following diagram. It illustrates the architecture of our sample system. We have three independent microservices, which register themself in service discovery, fetch properties from configuration service and communicate with each other. The whole system is hidden behind API gateway.

spring-cloud-1

Currently, the newest version of Spring Cloud is Finchley.M9. This version of spring-cloud-dependencies should be declared as a BOM for dependency management.

<dependencyManagement>
	<dependencies>
		<dependency>
			<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
			<artifactId>spring-cloud-dependencies</artifactId>
			<version>Finchley.M9</version>
			<type>pom</type>
			<scope>import</scope>
		</dependency>
	</dependencies>
</dependencyManagement>

Now, let’s consider the further steps to be taken in order to create working microservices-based system using Spring Cloud. We will begin from Configuration Server.

The source code of sample applications presented in this article is available on GitHub in repository https://github.com/piomin/sample-spring-microservices-new.git.

Step 1. Building configuration server with Spring Cloud Config

To enable Spring Cloud Config feature for an application, first include spring-cloud-config-server to your project dependencies.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-config-server</artifactId>
</dependency>

Then enable running embedded configuration server during application boot use @EnableConfigServer annotation.

@SpringBootApplication
@EnableConfigServer
public class ConfigApplication {

	public static void main(String[] args) {
		new SpringApplicationBuilder(ConfigApplication.class).run(args);
	}

}

By default Spring Cloud Config Server store the configuration data inside Git repository. This is very good choice in production mode, but for the sample purpose file system backend will be enough. It is really easy to start with config server, because we can place all the properties in the classpath. Spring Cloud Config by default search for property sources inside the following locations: classpath:/, classpath:/config, file:./, file:./config.

We place all the property sources inside src/main/resources/config. The YAML filename will be the same as the name of service. For example, YAML file for discovery-service will be located here: src/main/resources/config/discovery-service.yml.

And last two important things. If you would like to start config server with file system backend you have activate Spring Boot profile native. It may be achieved by setting parameter --spring.profiles.active=native during application boot. I have also changed the default config server port (8888) to 8061 by setting property server.port in bootstrap.yml file.

Step 2. Building service discovery with Spring Cloud Netflix Eureka

More to the point of configuration server. Now, all other applications, including discovery-service, need to add spring-cloud-starter-config dependency in order to enable config client. We also have to include dependency to spring-cloud-starter-netflix-eureka-server.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-netflix-eureka-server</artifactId>
</dependency>

Then you should enable running embedded discovery server during application boot by setting @EnableEurekaServer annotation on the main class.

@SpringBootApplication
@EnableEurekaServer
public class DiscoveryApplication {

	public static void main(String[] args) {
		new SpringApplicationBuilder(DiscoveryApplication.class).run(args);
	}

}

Application has to fetch property source from configuration server. The minimal configuration required on the client side is an application name and config server’s connection settings.

spring:
  application:
    name: discovery-service
  cloud:
    config:
      uri: http://localhost:8088

As I have already mentioned, the configuration file discovery-service.yml should be placed inside config-service module. However, it is required to say a few words about the configuration visible below. We have changed Eureka running port from default value (8761) to 8061. For standalone Eureka instance we have to disable registration and fetching registry.

server:
  port: 8061

eureka:
  instance:
    hostname: localhost
  client:
    registerWithEureka: false
    fetchRegistry: false
    serviceUrl:
      defaultZone: http://${eureka.instance.hostname}:${server.port}/eureka/

Now, when you are starting your application with embedded Eureka server you should see the following logs.

spring-cloud-2

Once you have succesfully started application you may visit Eureka Dashboard available under address http://localhost:8061/.

Step 3. Building microservice using Spring Boot and Spring Cloud

Our microservice has te perform some operations during boot. It needs to fetch configuration from config-service, register itself in discovery-service, expose HTTP API and automatically generate API documentation. To enable all these mechanisms we need to include some dependencies in pom.xml. To enable config client we should include starter spring-cloud-starter-config. Discovery client will be enabled for microservice after including spring-cloud-starter-netflix-eureka-client and annotating the main class with @EnableDiscoveryClient. To force Spring Boot application generating API documentation we should include springfox-swagger2 dependency and add annotation @EnableSwagger2.

Here is the full list of dependencies defined for my sample microservice.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-netflix-eureka-client</artifactId>
</dependency>
<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-config</artifactId>
</dependency>
<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.boot</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-boot-starter-web</artifactId>
</dependency>
<dependency>
	<groupId>io.springfox</groupId>
	<artifactId>springfox-swagger2</artifactId>
	<version>2.8.0</version>
</dependency>

And here is the main class of application that enables Discovery Client and Swagger2 for the microservice.

@SpringBootApplication
@EnableDiscoveryClient
@EnableSwagger2
public class EmployeeApplication {

	public static void main(String[] args) {
		SpringApplication.run(EmployeeApplication.class, args);
	}

	@Bean
	public Docket swaggerApi() {
		return new Docket(DocumentationType.SWAGGER_2)
			.select()
				.apis(RequestHandlerSelectors.basePackage("pl.piomin.services.employee.controller"))
				.paths(PathSelectors.any())
			.build()
			.apiInfo(new ApiInfoBuilder().version("1.0").title("Employee API").description("Documentation Employee API v1.0").build());
	}

	...

}

Application has to fetch configuration from a remote server, so we should only provide bootstrap.yml file with service name and server URL. In fact, this is the example of Config First Bootstrap approach, when an application first connects to a config server and takes a discovery server address from a remote property source. There is also Discovery First Bootstrap, where a config server address is fetched from a discovery server.

spring:
  application:
    name: employee-service
  cloud:
    config:
      uri: http://localhost:8088

There is no much configuration settings. Here’s application’s configuration file stored on a remote server. It stores only HTTP running port and Eureka URL. However, I also placed file employee-service-instance2.yml on remote config server. It sets different HTTP port for application, so you can esily run two instances of the same service locally basing on remote properties. Now, you may run the second instance of employee-service on port 9090 after passing argument spring.profiles.active=instance2 during an application startup. With default settings you will start the microservice on port 8090.

server:
  port: 9090

eureka:
  client:
    serviceUrl:
      defaultZone: http://localhost:8061/eureka/

Here’s the code with implementation of REST controller class. It provides an implementation for adding new employee and searching for employee using different filters.

@RestController
public class EmployeeController {

	private static final Logger LOGGER = LoggerFactory.getLogger(EmployeeController.class);

	@Autowired
	EmployeeRepository repository;

	@PostMapping
	public Employee add(@RequestBody Employee employee) {
		LOGGER.info("Employee add: {}", employee);
		return repository.add(employee);
	}

	@GetMapping("/{id}")
	public Employee findById(@PathVariable("id") Long id) {
		LOGGER.info("Employee find: id={}", id);
		return repository.findById(id);
	}

	@GetMapping
	public List findAll() {
		LOGGER.info("Employee find");
		return repository.findAll();
	}

	@GetMapping("/department/{departmentId}")
	public List findByDepartment(@PathVariable("departmentId") Long departmentId) {
		LOGGER.info("Employee find: departmentId={}", departmentId);
		return repository.findByDepartment(departmentId);
	}

	@GetMapping("/organization/{organizationId}")
	public List findByOrganization(@PathVariable("organizationId") Long organizationId) {
		LOGGER.info("Employee find: organizationId={}", organizationId);
		return repository.findByOrganization(organizationId);
	}

}

Step 4. Communication between microservice with Spring Cloud Open Feign

Our first microservice has been created and started. Now, we will add other microservices that communicate with each other. The following diagram illustrates the communication flow between three sample microservices: organization-service, department-service and employee-service. Microservice organization-service collect list of departments with (GET /organization/{organizationId}/with-employees) or without employees (GET /organization/{organizationId}) from department-service, and list of employees without dividing them into different departments directly from employee-service. Microservice department-service is able to collect list of employees assigned to the particular department.

spring-cloud-2

In the scenario described above both organization-service and department-service have to localize other microservices and communicate with them. That’s why we need to include additional dependency for those modules: spring-cloud-starter-openfeign. Spring Cloud Open Feign is a declarative REST client that used Ribbon client-side load balancer in order to communicate with other microservice.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-openfeign</artifactId>
</dependency>

The alternative solution to Open Feign is Spring RestTemplate with @LoadBalanced. However, Feign provides more ellegant way of defining client, so I prefer it instead of RestTemplate. After including the required dependency we should also enable Feign clients using @EnableFeignClients annotation.

@SpringBootApplication
@EnableDiscoveryClient
@EnableFeignClients
@EnableSwagger2
public class OrganizationApplication {

	public static void main(String[] args) {
		SpringApplication.run(OrganizationApplication.class, args);
	}

	...

}

Now, we need to define client’s interfaces. Because organization-service communicates with two other microservices we should create two interfaces, one per single microservice. Every client’s interface should be annotated with @FeignClient. One field inside annotation is required – name. This name should be the same as the name of target service registered in service discovery. Here’s the interface of the client that calls endpoint GET /organization/{organizationId} exposed by employee-service.

@FeignClient(name = "employee-service")
public interface EmployeeClient {

	@GetMapping("/organization/{organizationId}")
	List findByOrganization(@PathVariable("organizationId") Long organizationId);

}

The second client’s interface available inside organization-service calls two endpoints from department-service. First of them GET /organization/{organizationId} returns organization only with the list of available departments, while the second GET /organization/{organizationId}/with-employees return the same set of data including the list employees assigned to every department.

@FeignClient(name = "department-service")
public interface DepartmentClient {

	@GetMapping("/organization/{organizationId}")
	public List findByOrganization(@PathVariable("organizationId") Long organizationId);

	@GetMapping("/organization/{organizationId}/with-employees")
	public List findByOrganizationWithEmployees(@PathVariable("organizationId") Long organizationId);

}

Finally, we have to inject Feign client’s beans to the REST controller. Now, we may call the methods defined inside DepartmentClient and EmployeeClient, which is equivalent to calling REST endpoints.

@RestController
public class OrganizationController {

	private static final Logger LOGGER = LoggerFactory.getLogger(OrganizationController.class);

	@Autowired
	OrganizationRepository repository;
	@Autowired
	DepartmentClient departmentClient;
	@Autowired
	EmployeeClient employeeClient;

	...

	@GetMapping("/{id}")
	public Organization findById(@PathVariable("id") Long id) {
		LOGGER.info("Organization find: id={}", id);
		return repository.findById(id);
	}

	@GetMapping("/{id}/with-departments")
	public Organization findByIdWithDepartments(@PathVariable("id") Long id) {
		LOGGER.info("Organization find: id={}", id);
		Organization organization = repository.findById(id);
		organization.setDepartments(departmentClient.findByOrganization(organization.getId()));
		return organization;
	}

	@GetMapping("/{id}/with-departments-and-employees")
	public Organization findByIdWithDepartmentsAndEmployees(@PathVariable("id") Long id) {
		LOGGER.info("Organization find: id={}", id);
		Organization organization = repository.findById(id);
		organization.setDepartments(departmentClient.findByOrganizationWithEmployees(organization.getId()));
		return organization;
	}

	@GetMapping("/{id}/with-employees")
	public Organization findByIdWithEmployees(@PathVariable("id") Long id) {
		LOGGER.info("Organization find: id={}", id);
		Organization organization = repository.findById(id);
		organization.setEmployees(employeeClient.findByOrganization(organization.getId()));
		return organization;
	}

}

Step 5. Building API gateway using Spring Cloud Gateway

Spring Cloud Gateway is relatively new Spring Cloud project. It is built on top of Spring Framework 5, Project Reactor and Spring Boot 2.0. It requires the Netty runtime provided by Spring Boot and Spring Webflux. This is really nice alternative to Spring Cloud Netflix Zuul, which has been the only one Spring Cloud project providing API gateway for microservices until now.

API gateway is implemented inside module gateway-service. First, we should include starter spring-cloud-starter-gateway to the project dependencies.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-gateway</artifactId>
</dependency>

We also need to have discovery client enabled, because gateway-service integrates with Eureka in order to be able to perform routing to the downstream services. Gateway will also expose API specification of all the endpoints exposed by our sample microservices. That’s why we enabled Swagger2 also on the gateway.

@SpringBootApplication
@EnableDiscoveryClient
@EnableSwagger2
public class GatewayApplication {

	public static void main(String[] args) {
		SpringApplication.run(GatewayApplication.class, args);
	}

}

Spring Cloud Gateway provides three basic components used for configuration: routes, predicates and filters. Route is the basic building block of the gateway. It contains destination URI and list of defined predicates and filters. Predicate is responsible for matching on anything from the incoming HTTP request, such as headers or parameters. Filter may modify request and response before and after sending it to downstream services. All these components may be set using configuration properties. We will create and place on the confiration server file gateway-service.yml with the routes defined for our sample microservices.

But first, we should enable integration with discovery server for the routes by setting property spring.cloud.gateway.discovery.locator.enabled to true. Then we may proceed to defining the route rules. We use the Path Route Predicate Factory for matching the incoming requests, and the RewritePath GatewayFilter Factory for modifying the requested path to adapt it to the format exposed by downstream services. The uri parameter specifies the name of target service registered in discovery server. Let’s take a look on the following routes definition. For example, in order to make organization-service available on gateway under path /organization/**, we should define predicate Path=/organization/**, and then strip prefix /organization from the path, because the target service is exposed under path /**. The address of target service is fetched for Eureka basing uri value lb://organization-service.

spring:
  cloud:
    gateway:
      discovery:
        locator:
          enabled: true
      routes:
      - id: employee-service
        uri: lb://employee-service
        predicates:
        - Path=/employee/**
        filters:
        - RewritePath=/employee/(?.*), /$\{path}
      - id: department-service
        uri: lb://department-service
        predicates:
        - Path=/department/**
        filters:
        - RewritePath=/department/(?.*), /$\{path}
      - id: organization-service
        uri: lb://organization-service
        predicates:
        - Path=/organization/**
        filters:
        - RewritePath=/organization/(?.*), /$\{path}

Step 6. Enabling API specification on gateway using Swagger2

Every Spring Boot microservice that is annotated with @EnableSwagger2 exposes Swagger API documentation under path /v2/api-docs. However, we would like to have that documentation located in the single place – on API gateway. To achieve it we need to provide bean implementing SwaggerResourcesProvider interface inside gateway-service module. That bean is responsible for defining list storing locations of Swagger resources, which should be displayed by the application. Here’s the implementation of SwaggerResourcesProvider that takes the required locations from service discovery basing on the Spring Cloud Gateway configuration properties.

Unfortunately, SpringFox Swagger still does not provide support for Spring WebFlux. It means that if you include SpringFox Swagger dependencies to the project application will fail to start… I hope the support for WebFlux will be available soon, but now we have to use Spring Cloud Netflix Zuul as a gateway, if we would like to run embedded Swagger2 on it.

I created module proxy-service that is an alternative API gateway based on Netflix Zuul to gateway-service based on Spring Cloud Gateway. Here’s a bean with SwaggerResourcesProvider implementation available inside proxy-service. It uses ZuulProperties bean to dynamically load routes definition into the bean.

@Configuration
public class ProxyApi {

	@Autowired
	ZuulProperties properties;

	@Primary
	@Bean
	public SwaggerResourcesProvider swaggerResourcesProvider() {
		return () -> {
			List resources = new ArrayList();
			properties.getRoutes().values().stream()
					.forEach(route -> resources.add(createResource(route.getServiceId(), route.getId(), "2.0")));
			return resources;
		};
	}

	private SwaggerResource createResource(String name, String location, String version) {
		SwaggerResource swaggerResource = new SwaggerResource();
		swaggerResource.setName(name);
		swaggerResource.setLocation("/" + location + "/v2/api-docs");
		swaggerResource.setSwaggerVersion(version);
		return swaggerResource;
	}

}

Here’s Swagger UI for our sample microservices system available under address http://localhost:8060/swagger-ui.html.

spring-cloud-3

Step 7. Running applications

Let’s take a look on the architecture of our system visible on the following diagram. We will discuss it from the organization-service point of view. After starting organization-service connects to config-service available under address localhost:8088 (1). Basing on remote configuration settings it is able to register itself in Eureka (2). When the endpoint of organization-service is invoked by external client via gateway (3) available under address localhost:8060, the request is forwarded to instance of organization-service basing on entries from service discovery (4). Then organization-service lookup for address of department-service in Eureka (5), and call its endpoint (6). Finally department-service calls endpont from employee-service. The request as load balanced between two available instance of employee-service by Ribbon (7).

spring-cloud-3

Let’s take a look on the Eureka Dashboard available under address http://localhost:8061. There are four instances of microservices registered there: a single instance of organization-service and department-service, and two instances of employee-service.

spring-cloud-4

Now, let’s call endpoint http://localhost:8060/organization/1/with-departments-and-employees.

spring-cloud-5

Step 8. Correlating logs between independent microservices using Spring Cloud Sleuth

Correlating logs between different microservice using Spring Cloud Sleuth is very easy. In fact, the only thing you have to do is to add starter spring-cloud-starter-sleuth to the dependencies of every single microservice and gateway.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-sleuth</artifactId>
</dependency>

For clarification we will change default log format a little to: %d{yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss} ${LOG_LEVEL_PATTERN:-%5p} %m%n. Here are the logs generated by our three sample miccroservices. There are four entries inside braces [] generated by Spring Cloud Stream. The most important for us is the second entry, which indicates on traceId, that is set once per incoming HTTP request on the edge of the system.

spring-cloud-7

spring-cloud-6

spring-cloud-8

Advertisements

Circuit Breaker, Fallback and Load Balancing with Apache Camel

Apache Camel has just released a new version of their framework – 2.19. In one of my previous articles on DZone I described details about microservices support which was released in the Camel 2.18 version. There are some new features in ServiceCall EIP component, which is responsible for microservice calls. You can see example source code which is based on the sample from my article on DZone. It is available on GitHub under new branch fallback.

In the code fragment below you can see DLS route’s configuration with support for Hystrix circuit breaker, Ribbon load balancer and Consul service discovery and registration. As a service discovery in the route definition you can also use some other solutions instead of Consul like etcd (etcServiceDiscovery) or Kubernetes (kubernetesServiceDiscovery).

from("direct:account")
	.to("bean:customerService?method=findById(${header.id})")
	.log("Msg: ${body}").enrich("direct:acc", new AggregationStrategyImpl());

from("direct:acc").setBody().constant(null)
	.hystrix()
		.hystrixConfiguration()
			.executionTimeoutInMilliseconds(2000)
		.end()
	.serviceCall()
		.name("account//account")
		.component("netty4-http")
		.ribbonLoadBalancer("ribbon-1")
		.consulServiceDiscovery("http://192.168.99.100:8500")
	.end()
	.unmarshal(format)
	.endHystrix()
	.onFallback()
	.to("bean:accountFallback?method=getAccounts");

We can easily configure all Hystrix’s parameters just by calling hystrixConfiguration method. In the sample above Hystrix waits max 2 seconds for the response from remote service. In case of timeout fallback @Bean is called. Fallback @Bean implementation is really simple – it return empty list.

@Service
public class AccountFallback {

	public List<Account> getAccounts() {
		return new ArrayList<>();
	}

}

Alternatively, configuration can be implemented using object delarations. Here is service call configuration with Ribbon and Consul. Additionally, we can provide some parameters to Ribbon like client read timeout or max retry attempts. Unfortunately it seems they doesn’t work in this version of Apache Camel 🙂 (you can try to test it by yourself). I hope this will be corrected soon.

ServiceCallConfigurationDefinition def = new ServiceCallConfigurationDefinition();

ConsulConfiguration config = new ConsulConfiguration();
config.setUrl("http://192.168.99.100:8500");
config.setComponent("netty4-http");
ConsulServiceDiscovery discovery = new ConsulServiceDiscovery(config);

RibbonConfiguration c = new RibbonConfiguration();
c.addProperty("MaxAutoRetries", "0");
c.addProperty("MaxAutoRetriesNextServer", "1");
c.addProperty("ReadTimeout", "1000");
c.setClientName("ribbon-1");
RibbonServiceLoadBalancer lb = new RibbonServiceLoadBalancer(c);
lb.setServiceDiscovery(discovery);

def.setComponent("netty4-http");
def.setLoadBalancer(lb);
def.setServiceDiscovery(discovery);
context.setServiceCallConfiguration(def);

I described similar case for Spring Cloud and Netflix OSS in one of my previous article. Just like in the example presented there, I also set here a delay inside account service, which depends on the port on which the microservice was started.

@Value("${port}")
private int port;

public List<Account> findByCustomerId(Integer customerId) {
	List<Account> l = new ArrayList<>();
	l.add(new Account(1, "1234567890", 4321, customerId));
	l.add(new Account(2, "1234567891", 12346, customerId));
	if (port%2 == 0) {
		try {
			Thread.sleep(5000);
		} catch (InterruptedException e) {
			e.printStackTrace();
		}
	}
	return l;
}

Results for Spring Cloud sample were much more satisfying. The introduced configuration parameters such as read timeout for Ribbon worked and in addition Hystrix was able to automatically redirect a much smaller number of requests to slow service – only 2% of the rest to the non-blocking thread instance for 5 seconds. This shows that Apache Camel still has a few things to improve if wants to compete in microservice’s support with Sprint Cloud framework.

Part 3: Creating Microservices: Circuit Breaker, Fallback and Load Balancing with Spring Cloud

Probably you read some articles about Hystrix and you know in what purpose it is used for. Today I would like to show you an example of exactly how to use it, which gives you the ability to combine with other tools from Netflix OSS stack like Feign and Ribbon. In this I assume that you have basic knowledge on topics such as microservices, load balancing, service discovery. If not I suggest you read some articles about it, for example my short introduction to microservices architecture available here: Part 1: Creating microservice using Spring Cloud, Eureka and Zuul. The code sample used in that article is also also used now. There is also sample source code available on GitHub. For the sample described now see hystrix branch, for basic sample master branch. 

Let’s look at some scenarios for using fallback and circuit breaker. We have Customer Service which calls API method from Account Service. There two running instances of Account Service. The requests to Account Service instances are load balanced by Ribbon client 50/50.

micro-details-1

Scenario 1

Hystrix is disabled for Feign client (1), auto retries mechanism is disabled for Ribbon client on local instance (2) and other instances (3). Ribbon read timeout is shorter than request max process time (4). This scenario also occurs with the default Spring Cloud configuration without Hystrix. When you call customer test method you sometimes receive full response and sometimes 500 HTTP error code (50/50).

ribbon:
  eureka:
    enabled: true
  MaxAutoRetries: 0 #(2)
  MaxAutoRetriesNextServer: 0 #(3)
  ReadTimeout: 1000 #(4)

feign:
  hystrix:
    enabled: false #(1)

Scenario 2

Hystrix is still disabled for Feign client (1), auto retries mechanism is disabled for Ribbon client on local instance (2) but enabled on other instances once (3). You always receive full response. If your request is received by instance with delayed response it is timed out after 1 second and then Ribbon calls another instance – in that case not delayed. You can always change MaxAutoRetries to positive value but gives us nothing in that sample.

ribbon:
  eureka:
    enabled: true
  MaxAutoRetries: 0 #(2)
  MaxAutoRetriesNextServer: 1 #(3)
  ReadTimeout: 1000 #(4)

feign:
  hystrix:
    enabled: false #(1)

Scenario 3

Here is not a very elegant solution to the problem. We set ReadTimeout on value bigger than delay inside API method (5000 ms).

ribbon:
  eureka:
    enabled: true
  MaxAutoRetries: 0
  MaxAutoRetriesNextServer: 0
  ReadTimeout: 10000

feign:
  hystrix:
    enabled: false

Generally configuration from Scenario 2 and 3 is right, you always get the full response. But in some cases you will wait more than 1 second (Scenario 2) or more than 5 seconds (Scenario 3) and delayed instance receives 50% requests from Ribbon client. But fortunately there is Hystrix – circuit breaker.

Scenario 4

Let’s enable Hystrix just by removing feign property. There is no auto retries for Ribbon client (1) and its read timeout (2) is bigger than Hystrix’s timeout (3). 1000ms is also default value for Hystrix timeoutInMilliseconds property. Hystrix circuit breaker and fallback will work for delayed instance of account service. For some first requests you receive fallback response from Hystrix. Then delayed instance will be cut off from requests, most of them will be directed to not delayed instance.

ribbon:
  eureka:
    enabled: true
  MaxAutoRetries: 0 #(1)
  MaxAutoRetriesNextServer: 0
  ReadTimeout: 2000 #(2)

hystrix:
  command:
    default:
      execution:
        isolation:
          thread:
            timeoutInMilliseconds: 1000 #(3)

Scenario 5

This scenario is a more advanced development of Scenario 4. Now Ribbon timeout (2) is lower than Hystrix timeout (3) and also auto retries mechanism is enabled (1) for local instance and for other instances (4). The result is same as for Scenario 2 and 3 – you receive full response, but Hystrix is enabled and it cuts off delayed instance from future requests.

ribbon:
  eureka:
    enabled: true
  MaxAutoRetries: 3 #(1)
  MaxAutoRetriesNextServer: 1 #(4)
  ReadTimeout: 1000 #(2)

hystrix:
  command:
    default:
      execution:
        isolation:
          thread:
            timeoutInMilliseconds: 10000 #(3)

I could imagine a few other scenarios. But the idea was just a show differences in circuit breaker and fallback when modifying configuration properties for Feign, Ribbon and Hystrix in application.yml.

Hystrix

Let’s take a closer look on standard Hystrix circuit breaker and  usage described in Scenario 4. To enable Hystrix in your Spring Boot application you have to following dependencies to pom.xml. Second step is to add annotation @EnableCircuitBreaker to main application class and also @EnableHystrixDashboard if you would like to have UI dashboard available.

<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-hystrix</artifactId>
</dependency>
<dependency>
	<groupId>org.springframework.cloud</groupId>
	<artifactId>spring-cloud-starter-hystrix-dashboard</artifactId>
</dependency>

Hystrix fallback is set on Feign client inside customer service.

@FeignClient(value = "account-service", fallback = AccountFallback.class)
public interface AccountClient {

    @RequestMapping(method = RequestMethod.GET, value = "/accounts/customer/{customerId}")
    List<Account> getAccounts(@PathVariable("customerId") Integer customerId);

}

Fallback implementation is really simple. In this case I just return empty list instead of customer’s account list received from account service.

@Component
public class AccountFallback implements AccountClient {

	@Override
	public List<Account> getAccounts(Integer customerId) {
		List<Account> acc = new ArrayList<Account>();
		return acc;
	}

}

Now, we can perform some tests. Let’s start discovery service, two instances of account service on different ports (-DPORT VM argument during startup) and customer service. Endpoint for tests is /customers/{id}. There is also JUnit test class which sends multiple requests to this enpoint available in customer-service module pl.piomin.microservices.customer.ApiTest.

	@RequestMapping("/customers/{id}")
	public Customer findById(@PathVariable("id") Integer id) {
		logger.info(String.format("Customer.findById(%s)", id));
		Customer customer = customers.stream().filter(it -> it.getId().intValue()==id.intValue()).findFirst().get();
		List<Account> accounts =  accountClient.getAccounts(id);
		customer.setAccounts(accounts);
		return customer;
	}

I enabled Hystrix Dashboard on account-service main class. If you would like to access it call from your web browser http://localhost:2222/hystrix address and then type Hystrix’s stream address from customer-service http://localhost:3333/hystrix.stream. When I run test that sends 1000 requests to customer service about 20 (2%) of them were forwarder to delayed instance of account service, remaining to not delayed instance. Hystrix dashboard during that test is visible below. For more advanced Hystrix configuration refer to its documentation available here.

hystrix-1